Content added Content deleted
No edit summary |
m (→History and Controversy: Added Archive Template) |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
== History and Controversy == |
== History and Controversy == |
||
A moderator on the askanonbinary Tumblr blog created the word "aliagender" in response to an ask by the user Zobothehobo. It was coined some time before January 20, 2014<ref>https://askanonbinary.tumblr.com/post/74027274913/alia-is-wonderful-wow-i-love-the-way-it-sounds</ref>. Zobothehobo later described this event: "i was there when aliagender was coined. actually, i was the reason it was coined. I sent messages to askanonbinary and beck came up with the word. we defined it then as a gender experience other from the traditional spectrum. I always meant for this to be a term for a specific positive gender that was not associated with the man/woman spectrum, but was a gender that existed and NOT genderless."<ref>https://zobothehobo.com/post/91716663005/epochryphal-throws-up-hands-im-getting-really</ref> |
A moderator on the askanonbinary Tumblr blog created the word "aliagender" in response to an ask by the user Zobothehobo. It was coined some time before January 20, 2014<ref>{{Archive|Site=web|URL=https://askanonbinary.tumblr.com/post/74027274913/alia-is-wonderful-wow-i-love-the-way-it-sounds}}</ref>. Zobothehobo later described this event: "i was there when aliagender was coined. actually, i was the reason it was coined. I sent messages to askanonbinary and beck came up with the word. we defined it then as a gender experience other from the traditional spectrum. I always meant for this to be a term for a specific positive gender that was not associated with the man/woman spectrum, but was a gender that existed and NOT genderless."<ref>{{Archive|Site=web|URL=https://zobothehobo.com/post/91716663005/epochryphal-throws-up-hands-im-getting-really}}</ref> |
||
Soon after, there was a conflict about whether the word was politically problematic. Some individuals of color reportedly said "that aliagender is racist in that it is basically just a whitewashed version of third gender." In response, another individual coined [[aporagender]] as an alternative to aliagender, due to concerns that aliagender might be "racist or appropriative." Zobothehobo said they did not intend for aliagender to be harmful in anyway, and was created to describe an "othering" concept of gender. |
Soon after, there was a conflict about whether the word was politically problematic. Some individuals of color reportedly said "that aliagender is racist in that it is basically just a whitewashed version of third gender." In response, another individual coined [[aporagender]] as an alternative to aliagender, due to concerns that aliagender might be "racist or appropriative." Zobothehobo said they did not intend for aliagender to be harmful in anyway, and was created to describe an "othering" concept of gender. |
||
Vesper H., the blogger and vlogger behind Queer as Cat, has written against claims that terms such as aliagender, aporagender, and maverique (which they coined) are racist. According to Vesper, themself black, where third gender is "a prescriptive term forced onto others without their consent"<ref name=":0">https://queerascat.tumblr.com/post/137554950446/re-maverique-aporagender-aliagender-and-third</ref> used to other cultural identities, terms such as aliagender were specific gender identities that were not used to contain and erase cultural identities.<ref name=":0" /> |
Vesper H., the blogger and vlogger behind Queer as Cat, has written against claims that terms such as aliagender, aporagender, and maverique (which they coined) are racist. According to Vesper, themself black, where third gender is "a prescriptive term forced onto others without their consent"<ref name=":0">{{Archive|Site=web|URL=https://queerascat.tumblr.com/post/137554950446/re-maverique-aporagender-aliagender-and-third}}</ref> used to other cultural identities, terms such as aliagender were specific gender identities that were not used to contain and erase cultural identities.<ref name=":0" /> |
||
==Flag and Symbols== |
==Flag and Symbols== |
||